sherlock holmes actors

Episode 43: Ranking the Sherlocks

Elementary, dear listener…

For this episode, Tom and Morgan pick three actors who have played Sherlock Holmes, before agreeing on an overall ranking of the very best on-screen Sherlocks of all time.

We also discuss a few honourable mentions, the difference between a ‘bumbling’ or ‘capable’ John Watson and the politics of the deerstalker hat.

The main six actors we focus on are:

  • Basil Rathbone
  • Peter Cushing
  • Robert Downey Jr
  • Robert Stephens
  • Benedict Cumberbatch
  • Jeremy Brett

Download the episode, stream in the player above, or subscribe for the latest episodes.

Make sure to check out all our previous episodes, including when we ranked Scrooge actors and looked back at James Bond films.

Get in touch with us at, or via FacebookTwitter or Instagram.

Please support us Patreon here, and get some awesome exclusive Two Geeks goodies!

Leave a Reply